Friday, April 29, 2016

Doubt, Temptation, and Certainty

Rev. Stephen E. Stults
St. Paul’s Anglican Church
Feb. 14th, 2016

Mat 4:3
“And when the tempter came to him, he said, If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread.”

Three words: doubt, temptation, and certainty. These three words sum up the Lenten experience for some.  It may sum up the Christian life for most. Let us consider these three words: doubt, temptation, certainty. If we are being honest with ourselves, it is probable that we will experience all three in this season of Lent.

Similarly, the Gospel for the day goes to the very heart of what it is to be a Christian , as it focuses on these three powerful realities.  In the opening lines of the Gospel passage we read, from Mat. 4:1:”Then was Jesus led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted of the devil.”

Recall that at the end of the previous chapter of Matthew, Chapter 3, Christ has just come from His baptism in the river Jordan at the hands of John the Baptizer.  In that amazing scene, the Spirit of God had just descended upon Jesus and a voice from heaven had said, “This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.” Christ submitted to baptism even though He had no original sin to wash away, thus giving us the model of Christian Baptism.  He also received glory and recognition from God the Father.  

Oftentimes, honor precedes humbling or trials; as one commentator tells us: “After we have been admitted into the communion of God, we must expect to be set upon by Satan. The enriched soul must double its guard.”[1] Thus, in our Gospel selection, St. Matthew describes the temptation of Christ.  In it, Satan tries to something audacious and evil. In effect, he attempts to undo God’s Plan by the invocation of one little word, “if.” Christ had just been exalted, and now as Matthew tells us in Mat 4: “Then was Jesus led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted of the devil.” 

Many commentators on this passage have wondered why Jesus Christ would  submit to such a situation.  Although there is much discussion of this, we may safely assume three areas of consensus:
1.                  Christ suffered temptation that he might fully identify with all aspects of         our human condition, yet without sin.
2.                  Christ battled with Satan and overcame him, not in evidence of divine power, but in the absence of any outward manifestations of power.
3.                  Christ, in his human nature, exhibited complete reliance upon His Father and his Holy Word, thus giving us the perfect model.

We note with interest that there were three temptations. The first temptation deals with Christ’s physical well-being, as Satan tempted him to make bread out of stones. This attack is both insulting and predatory.  Satan introduces the assault by saying, “If thou be the Son of God…”  Is Satan, the Great Deceiver, seeking to cause Jesus to doubt himself in his physical weakness?  As ludicrous as it seems, this is the case.  Satan, in arrogance, evidently thought this attack might work. Of course, the idea of causing the Son of God to doubt himself is absurd and fanciful.  Yet, once again, the point is plain; if Satan tried to get God the Son Himself to doubt, what will he try with us?
This leads to the predatory aspect of Satan’s attack on Christ.  Because he is wicked and a brilliant tactician, the Devil attacks us when we are weak.
Be it through physical need, sickness, melancholy, or (God forbid) despair, he seeks a chink in our spiritual armor.  He wants to insinuate his infernal suggestions, temptations and fears. Yes, there are times when all of us, being  subject to the weaknesses of the flesh, fall prey to his devices.  Yet, by keeping  our spiritual eyes on Christ, we will frustrate the plans of the devil.  In this instance, Christ dismisses Satan’s assault with a word of Scripture.  From Deut. 8:3, Christ said: “And he humbled thee, and suffered thee to hunger, and fed thee with manna, which thou knewest not, neither did thy fathers know; that he might make thee know that man doth not live by bread only, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of the LORD doth man live.” Satan is rebuffed.

Having failed in his first attempt, Satan then takes another approach, this time appealing to Jesus’ physical safety, and to the very image of who He Is.  Jesus is taken to a pinnacle of the Temple in Jerusalem.  Again, there comes the insult and the word of doubt: “If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down…”  Herein is a great lesson concerning the nature of sin and Our Adversary’s dealing with us.  Note that Satan does not throw Christ off the pinnacle himself, thus doing Him direct harm, but rather, suggests that Jesus “cast” himself down.  We learn  here Satan has no direct power over us but is limited to the power we give him.  Sin always requires an active response from us in some assent of the will

In this case, Satan’s temptation is obvious and flagrant.  Once, again, Christ repels him with a word from Scripture, “It is written again, Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God.” Some commentators have interpreted this as “Don’t presume  God to save you when you engage in some self-destructive or sinful act, in exercise of your free will.”[2]  Yet, even when we behave in a flagrantly sinful way, or are self-destructive, God in his mercy often mitigates the ill effects of our actions. He may also allow us to realize the consequences of our sins to teach us. While God forgives us our sin, the “scar tissue” of our misdeeds remain.  Forgiveness abounds from God’s mercy when we truly repent, but the consequences of our sin are a lasting reminder of our rebellion against God.

It is not so with Christ.  Satan is defeated again with a rebuke from Scripture, but not without one more insidious and persistent attack; by an appeal to Jesus’ pride.  In a twisted, perverted view of Christ’s Kingship, Satan shows Jesus all the earthly glory.  In Mat 4:8 “Again, the devil taketh him up into an exceeding high mountain, and sheweth him all the kingdoms of the world, and the glory of them.” At last, Christ’s patience is exhausted, for as the Tempter says, “All these things will I give thee, if thou wilt fall down and worship me.” Christ expels him a command: “Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.”

This is the so-called “last straw” for Christ. The idea of the Lord prostrating Himself before this hideous fallen angel is too much.  Christ speaks with authority and the Devil leaves, defeated and frustrated. The victory is won and the angels, who have been watching this contest with worshipful admiration, come and minister to Jesus. Satan had done his best and had failed.  Just as Christ would later defeat Satan completely on the battleground of Calvary, so he is now vanquished.

At the start of this homily, I mentioned that this passage “goes to the very heart of what we believe and experience as Christians.” It speaks to the twin infernal phenomena of doubt and temptation. Concerning doubt, Satan used the “if” word three times, once for each temptation: “if thou be the Son of God, “if” thou be the Son of God, and “if” thou wilt fall down and worship me.”  
Each of these is a conditional statement that seeks to provoke doubt or sin. Each time, Satan seeks to cause Jesus to question Himself, and/or he mockingly insinuates that Jesus Christ is not the eternal Son, and the Spotless Lamb of God.

If this were true, Christianity would be shattered.  If Christ is not who He says He is, the Son of the Almighty God and the Lord and Savior of Mankind, we are confounded and hopeless.  If Christ is not the Son of God, we might as well submit to the toothless doctrine of the Enlightenment, where Christ’s dying on the Cross is not substitutionary, but merely a supreme example of what a good man does.  Finally, if we worship an “If” God, we Christians are, in the words of St. Paul, the most miserable of all people. 

Thanks be to God, because instead of doubt, we have certainty. St. Paul says, “But, now is Christ risen from the dead and become the first fruits of them that slept.” [i]  In the eternal sense, now is our Savior Christ victorious over sin, death, hell, and the Devil.  We can meet the twin evils of doubt and temptation and emerge victorious. We do not worship an “If” God. No, we worship a God of certainty. We worship He who is the same yesterday, today and tomorrow.   

AMEN


[1] http://blueletterbible.org/Comm/mhc/Mat/Mat004.html, Mathew Henry, “Commentary on Matthew”
[2] Ibid



[i] I Cor. 15:20

No comments:

Post a Comment